Prosecutors conclude their case in murder trial of Cristhian Rivera

National News

NOTE: Some evidence presented during the trial may contain graphic images.

DAVENPORT, Iowa (AP) — An agent who oversaw the 2018 investigation into the disappearance of a University of Iowa student testified Monday that a shortage of Spanish-speaking officers delayed and hindered his ability to question the man on trial in her stabbing death.

Division of Criminal Investigation agent Trent Vileta said he wanted to speak with Cristhian Bahena Rivera after investigators linked him to a car seen on video driving near where Mollie Tibbetts disappeared while running in Brooklyn, Iowa.

But that took four days, in part because investigators knew they needed to question Bahena Rivera and his co-workers in Spanish, and “we didn’t have any Spanish speakers,” Vileta said.

Vileta testified at the Scott County Courthouse in Davenport as the first-degree murder trial of Bahena Rivera entered its second week. Bahena Rivera, 26, faces life in prison if convicted.

Prosecutors say Bahena Rivera followed Tibbetts while she ran on July 18, 2018, killed her after she threatened to call police then hid her body in a cornfield. They say Bahena Rivera led investigators to the body after making a partial confession on Aug. 20, 2018, and that Tibbetts’ DNA was a match for blood found in his trunk.

Vileta acknowledged Monday that investigators never found a murder weapon and do not have physical evidence proving Bahena Rivera killed her, only that her body was in his vehicle’s trunk. Bahena Rivera told police that he “blacked out” and couldn’t remember how he killed Tibbetts.

Vileta said the evidence suggests Tibbetts was abducted on a road outside Brooklyn after 8 p.m., but that he does not know precisely where or when she was killed.

Data from Tibbetts’ cellphone provider shows her phone was moving at a running pace before accelerating to over 60 mph around 8:27 p.m. and eventually slowing down and stopping more than 10 miles away, FBI agent Kevin Horan testified. By 8:53 p.m., her phone went dark.

Agents narrowed their focus to that rural area near the town of Guernsey, where her body was later found. Her cellphone and FitBit device were never recovered, Vileta said.

An autopsy determined Tibbetts died of multiple sharp-force injuries consistent with stab wounds from a knife with a single-edged blade, State Medical Examiner Dennis Klein told jurors Monday afternoon.

Tibbetts suffered up to 12 wounds to her head, neck, chest and other body parts, including one injury that penetrated her skull, he said. An injury to her right hand suggested she was trying to defend herself.

Bahena Rivera remained largely expressionless throughout the day. He watched as the medical examiner discussed several photos showing the wounds to Tibbetts’ body, which had decomposed by the time it was recovered.

After identifying Bahena Rivera as a person of interest Aug. 16, Vileta said he had to find Spanish-speaking officers to question the Mexican national and other dairy farm workers, describing that four-day gap as “a nervous time.”

Vileta noted that the “ political environment ” for immigrants living illegally in the U.S. was hostile in 2018, and said he worried that Bahena Rivera or others might flee if they knew they were being sought for questioning. That’s why investigators took DNA samples from Hispanic workers at the farm, so they could be identified if they later disappeared, he said.

Vileta said he asked Iowa City police officer Pamela Romero to question Rivera because she is fluent in Spanish, even though she had little interrogation experience.

He said he opted not to have Romero translate his questions for Bahena Rivera because doing so would make for a choppy and frustrating discussion, and had Romero continue the interview because Bahena Rivera seemed comfortable speaking with her.

Vileta said he and an FBI agent tried to manage the 11-hour interview by taking frequent breaks so they could be briefed on Bahena Rivera’s statements, but that it was difficult.

On cross-examination, Vileta recounted looking into Mollie Tibbetts’ boyfriend and other men who came under scrutiny for various reasons before Bahena Rivera came on their radar. That included a reserve deputy who lived on the property adjacent to where Tibbetts’ body was found, Vileta said.

Tipsters told police that the man had a “torture room” in his basement and had previously harmed women and children, Vileta acknowledged. Investigators went to the man’s house, did not find such a room and never formally interviewed him, he said.

Seeking to rebut suggestions that someone else could have been responsible for Tibbetts’ death, prosecutor Scott Brown raised his voice to a shout as he asked Vileta whether anyone else had confessed or been linked to the death of Tibbetts by blood evidence. Vileta said only Rivera.

“That person is the man seated here to my right, would you agree?” Brown said, pointing at Bahena Rivera.


DAVENPORT, Iowa — The second week of Cristhian Rivera’s murder trial got off to a frustrating start Monday morning due to the impact of a technical malfunction, COVID-19 protocols, and a courthouse construction project.

Rivera is accused of killing 20-year-old Mollie Tibbetts in July of 2018 and hiding her body in a cornfield near Guernsey.

The sound system in the courtroom kept broadcasting static or feedback, as prosecutor Scott Brown questioned the prosecution’s first witness of the day, Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation agent Trent Vileta. That noise flustered Brown, who asked Judge Joel Yates whether it could be fixed.

Court staff then turned off the sound system and the questioning continued without microphones. But jurors in the back of the courtroom indicated they had problems hearing Vileta’s testimony.

Yates called a break just 15 minutes into the day as his staff called in a technical person to fix the system, but learned that person was an hour away from Davenport.

Brown said that he wanted to continue because prosecutors hoped to wrap up their case Monday, and that will require the lawyers and witnesses to speak up.

Vileta’s testimony resumed at 9:00 a.m. without microphones, as banging noises from a construction project could be heard in the background.

Prosecutor Scott Brown raised his voice loudly and pointed at Cristhian Bahena Rivera across the courtroom as he argued he was the only suspect who could have killed Mollie Tibbetts.

Brown’s theatrics came as he questioned the lead agent in Tibbetts’ 2018 disappearance, seeking to rebut suggestions by the defense that other men who came under scrutiny could have been responsible for her death.

His voice at times booming into a yell, Brown asked Division of Criminal Investigation agent Trent Vileta a series of questions about whether anyone else had confessed to the crime or had Tibbetts’ blood found in their vehicle. Vileta said no, that only Rivera had.

“That person is the man seated here to my right, would you agree?” Brown said, pointing at Bahena Rivera. The exchange came after Vileta acknowledged under cross-examination that investigators had taken a close look at a number of other persons during the monthlong search for Tibbetts, before Bahena Rivera came on their radar.

As a reminder, jurors are not sitting in the normal jury box near the witnesses because of Iowa Supreme Court rules requiring that they socially distance. Instead, they are spread out in four rows of seats where spectators would usually sit, six feet apart. Those in the back are much farther away than jurors would normally be.

None of the jurors have been wearing masks in the courtroom. Days before the trial, the Iowa Supreme Court changed its rules to reflect the latest CDC guidance, allowing people who are fully vaccinated to go maskless during court proceedings.

The trial is being held at the Scott County Courthouse in Davenport. It was moved out of Poweshiek County due to pre-trial publicity of the case. 

You can look back at previous stories about the case here.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.